This Page

has been moved to new address

CRASH into me

Sorry for inconvenience...

Redirection provided by Blogger to WordPress Migration Service
various rambling thoughts: CRASH into me

Thursday, April 06, 2006

CRASH into me



Moving at the speed of light, we are bound to collide with each other…..

That’s the tag line….though its more than that….its the whole wisdom of the film encapsulated into those lines…..


Watched the movie a couple of days back and I can say with all certainty that it is one of the best movies I have seen….


The title is apt for what follows and you see the word in almost every frame of the movie…..the characters keep bumping into each other, and at each time, we get to learn something more about them, and by the time the film ends, one realizes that the first impressions are never the last ones…..

The villain becomes the saviour almost at the cost of his own life, the conscientious one shows that he too is a victim of racial stereotyping without he, himself being aware of it…..the woman who seemed to have it all, shows at the end that what she really wants is not what she has….the ones who are considered the classical victims of racism are shown to be not above racism themselves, if not overtly but in their mind, in their thinking in stereotypes (when Ecuador and El Salvador lose their identity and the whole of Latin America become Mexico, just like Africans are Africans as if Africa is a country)

The words that Matt Dillon says to his partner perhaps symbolize the whole film “do you think you know who you are? Eh?.....You have no idea”

Racism of all types, of all varieties is interwoven in the storyline, in fact it IS the story….and in between, the lives (both visible and invisible to others) of the players, crash into the situations, that arise due their flitting across each other’s lives…..here one realizes the burden of his identity and finds a reason to fight back and there some one else finds some redemption, another one is initially painted a villain but finally we are made to realize that so many of our instant classifications are simplistic, here one more is shown to be idealistic but falls into the same mental trap for which he accuses the other. The desperations and quiet tragedy and triumphs of individual lives, whether of a person who is trying to build his roots or of a person who is not sure anymore whether the ones she chose were the right ones, is overlain in the script.











The film for me is very radical in its political and social outlook.

This is because these are issues not easy to deal with, especially as we still rely on age old definitions of our various problems, whether the problem is racism or personal misunderstandings and failures. These are issues that urgently need to be dealt with and that is why one comes out of the theatres feeling battered by our own senses….the movie just kicks us out of our comfort zones, all of them, and forces us to look within…..forces us to question our own assumptions and hidden prejudices. It just shakes you….and it feels better after having been shaken up, since so few things seem to shake us these days…..and its made better by the fact that the script does not allow for a classic storytelling, there is actually no ‘story’ as such (as we understand by a story), just perhaps crashes of all sorts….it prevents us from escaping from what the film is all about, prevents us from immersing ourselves vicariously in the story and reject the message within…..a story develops no doubt, but not in the way most of us are comfortable with…..therein lies the strength and magic of this movie…..

It’s a movie that I would carry with me for a long long time…..

6 Comments:

At 8:15 PM, Blogger Vipul said...

hmm.. so u liked it.. for me it was one of worst movie.. i felt bluffed.. it is all about america that too not shown properly.. must say the most pathetic movie to win an oscar..and that concurs with it being voted as one of the worst movie to won an oscar they just gave it for racism..

"the movie just kicks us out of our comfort zones, all of them, and forces us to look within"

oh does it..?? turned out to be poor joke for me..
if u think it is one of the best movie u've seen then i am sure you havent even heard the names of pianist,schindler's list,shawshank redemption..
no offences meant..
vipfloyd from PG

 
At 11:26 AM, Blogger Protik Basu said...

"it is all about america that too not shown properly"

really? and you know what america is? maybe you are of the tribe who believes that america is about walmarts and disneyland....if that is so, its about time you try and lift your self-imposed blinkers....

perhaps you are not aware that the 'melting pot' that is suposedly america has always been an illusion...it is economic neccesity in many cases that has led them to open the doors to their country....and the movie shows that and more, and it also shows that the problem about which we feel so comfortable about (and which we think has been solved to a large extent) - anti-black racism, is not only alive and well but has taken different colours....but you wont know that unless you chuck yr chetan bhagats and dan browns and sam waltons away and read some real books on real people on real issues....

and btw i dunno what votes u are talking about (hope u donnt read TOI...cuz they have a penchant for picking up weird surveys which i suspect are all made up)....

and btw i dunno if wrote it in the blog or not, but if someone comes out of the theatre and says he felt nothing, then he is either a liar or a empty-headed mall-rat...i dunno which one is you....

and pianist, schlinder's list (where does shawshank redemption figure here? do u know what the story is about or are u one of those who like to drop names to sound impressive??), are different movies tackling different topics...ab the schlinder's list, dont believe all that u see in the movie....spielberg, like ridley scott is not much of a historian anyway.....

and in any case both are cut and dry war movies and dont display the nuances of racism that has taken form today...they are more or less stories in black and white...good guy, bad guy....good german, bad german etc...nothing complex....no catch22 there...

and buddy, if u gotta drop names, try and pick names next time that makes it known that you understand cinema, dont just start shooting names without knowing what the films are about....

 
At 3:24 PM, Blogger Vipul said...

whatever!! u've gone too personal while we are discussing about a movie.. and about dropping names,i never said they are in same topics.. i said those are the marvels of cinema and crash is nowhere close to them ..

and talking about the movie it is not the idea but the approach- which is total shit.. just some 10 people keep banging upon each other every other scene,white racists are redeemed,the film with such a contoversial topic is supposed to clever,authentic and somewat realistic,but characters of sandra bullock,brenden frazer,ryan phillipe are like jokes,and even american movie critics said same.. some of the scenes were totally arbit. i tried hard to be serious but ........
black people are exaggeratedly comic white folks are shown tragic.. idea and maybe intention to show smg is good but really the scripts is totally flawed. there was iranian father shaun toub whose store is vandalized one day,perhaps the director didnt know there is a very well built iranian community in LA,arab would have been better LOL.
seems like you are also one the person who falled for hoopla surrounding crash being an achievement in a very principled hollywood,or for an oscar it got..
crappy stuff!!!

take a look what msnbc has to say
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/11700333/

before ur reply just take this thing in ur mind,we are talking about movie and this movie has really dealt a very important topic in a real bad/arbit manner.
regards
vipul

 
At 5:09 PM, Blogger Protik Basu said...

hmm, what i understand yr main grouse about the film is the stereotyping that you feel the film has got its characters into (from what i could gather from yr post and the MSN article that you gave the link to)....

and i do see that some columnists have expressed similar feelings....

however i failed to see stereotyping, stereotyping is when blacks are shown to be loony characters talking always in a particular accent and so on (a point shown starkly and criticized in the film itself), it is when whites are shown to be racists or worse bleeding heart liberals (the ones lampooned in phil och's song 'love me, i am a liberal')....

i did not see any white racists being redeemed, in a way we are shown what drives racism....we are shown the cause of dillon's anger against the african american community, which although justifying nothing, shows what a life of frustruation can do when you havnt developed the maturity and you look for a scapegoat to channelize your anger and whom you see as the reason for your life's failures and your lack of power, (why do you think dillon molests the woman?)....in the end its not about racism but the stereotypes that we carry in our mind...thats the reason why the the black man gets shot when the other thought he was pulling out his gun (whoa...black...must be having a gun)...i america, believe me, it is like that...go to florida, people are afraid to go out in some areas in the dark....in the end its a vicious cycle...

the article says that sandra bullock wouldnt have said what she said in front of the locksmith...why the hell not??? she is a powerful man's wife who is almost at the end of her tether....and she would not consider the locksmith as a proper human being anyway....havnt we all experienced situation like those?

its a complex film and it would not serve us to just look at individual frames to justify its goodness or badness....but in its wholeness....for my part, i did not see any easy solutions offered...in the end, the question of who is the 'good guy' and who the 'bad guy' is almost an irrelevant question....all are shown to be weak in some ways....everybody is just trying to find a way out....

one more point, i did not carry any pre-concieved notion in my mind when i went to see it....i saw it with as much openess of mind as i saw brokeback....so i didnt 'fall' for anything...its upto you to believe me,of course...

and about marvels of cinema, thats again a stereotype....we see what the media moghuls back....i have found 'requiem for a dream', 'miss monday' etc to be masterpeices but a tiny minority have heard of them, much less seen them...on the other hand, 'the ten commandments','the last emporer', are considered masterpeices...the best movies are usually the ones we seldom see...

 
At 9:59 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I watched 'Crash' and liked it very much and I don't think this movie applies to only America..Racism is pervasive and unfortunately, I think, all of us, at some point in our lives have said, done or acted in a way that smacks of racism. This movie tried to show that and make us realize how even a bit of racism can lead to terrible consequences.

 
At 11:40 AM, Blogger Protik Basu said...

yes, its true....its based in america but not confined to that country....

 

Post a Comment

<< Home